A peer-to-peer review is a conversation between a hospital's physician and a payor's medical reviewer about a disputed medical necessity decision. It can be the fastest route to resolving a denial or a disputed level-of-care decision, and it goes better when the clinical record is organized and the right physician is on the call. This guide covers what Medicare Advantage rules say about who reviews a denial, how hospitals prepare, and where physician peer-to-peer review coordination fits in denial prevention. It is a general summary, not legal advice.
What Is a Peer-to-Peer Review?
It is a physician-to-physician discussion of a case the payor has questioned. On the hospital side, physician advisors take part: they perform concurrent secondary reviews, join peer-to-peer discussions with payors, and write formal appeals to overturn clinical denials[4].
What Do Medicare Advantage Rules Say About Who Reviews a Denial?
Two Medicare Advantage rules address the reviewer, not the call itself. Before a plan issues a partially or fully adverse medical necessity decision based on its initial review, the request must be reviewed by a physician or other appropriate health care professional with expertise in the field of medicine or health care that is appropriate for the services at issue, including knowledge of Medicare coverage criteria[1]. That reviewer does not always have to be of the same specialty or subspecialty as the treating physician[1].
If the plan later reconsiders a denial based on a lack of medical necessity, the decision must be made by a physician with expertise appropriate for the services at issue, and by someone who was not involved in making the original determination[2].
| Stage | Who reviews | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Medicare Advantage initial adverse medical necessity decision | A physician or other appropriate health care professional with expertise suited to the services at issue, before the decision is issued | 42 CFR §422.566(d)[1] |
| Medicare Advantage reconsideration of a medical necessity denial | A physician with appropriate expertise who was not involved in the original determination | 42 CFR §422.590(h)[2] |
| A hospital's own finding that an admission or continued stay is not medically necessary | One utilization review (UR) committee member if the responsible practitioner concurs or does not present views, otherwise at least two members, after consulting the practitioner | 42 CFR §482.30(d)[3] |
In a June 2022 letter to CMS, the American College of Physician Advisors asked CMS to clarify Medicare Advantage plans' obligations regarding peer-to-peer discussions[5]. Confirm each payor's process and contract terms before relying on any one assumption.
Does the Hospital Have a Physician Review Rule Too?
Yes. Medicare's hospital utilization review rule has its own physician-to-physician step. Before the UR committee decides that an admission or continued stay is not medically necessary, it must consult the practitioner responsible for the patient's care and give that practitioner the opportunity to present their views[3].
Physician Peer-to-Peer Review Coordination: How Hospitals Prepare
bServed coordinates peer-to-peer involvement through its physician advisors, who are engaged on borderline and disputed cases and on denials that need to be contested. Its physician peer-to-peer review coordination service includes:
- Physician advisor involvement for all borderline or disputed cases
- Proactive physician advisor engagement before denial risk escalates
- Escalation to a physician advisor for cases approaching criteria thresholds
- Complete, payor-aligned clinical packets prepared in advance
A peer-to-peer goes further when the physician knows exactly which criteria the payor applied. For Medicare Advantage plans, that question has a regulatory side: see When Medicare Advantage Denies a Continued Stay, Ask Which Criteria It Used. bServed's medical necessity review services deliver criteria-aligned InterQual and MCG clinical reviews, and InterQual vs. MCG: Clinical Reviews Explained covers how the two criteria sets differ.
Where Peer-to-Peer Fits in Hospital Denial Prevention
Physician advisor involvement works best early, before denial risk escalates. That is the focus of Hospital Denial Prevention, and it relies on daily inpatient concurrent review services that surface cases while the patient is still in the hospital. That is real-time utilization management: the review happens during the stay, when the record can still be strengthened. When a denial does occur, the same physicians support Appeals & Denial Recovery.
Across five verified hospital engagements, bServed delivered 40% to 43% reductions in payor denials. At Hospital 4, daily medical necessity review cut concurrent denials by 40%. bServed also owns MGear, whose denial management module creates appeals automatically from upheld physician-advisor outcomes.
Sources
[1] 42 CFR §422.566, Organization determinations (Legal Information Institute)
[2] 42 CFR §422.590, Timeframes and responsibility for reconsiderations (Legal Information Institute)
[3] 42 CFR §482.30, Condition of Participation: Utilization Review (Legal Information Institute)
[4] Marina Farah, MD, MHA, "What Hospitalists Need to Know About Health Care Reimbursement and Denial Prevention," The Hospitalist
[5] American College of Physician Advisors, "Letter to CMS about the 2022 OIG Report on MAOs," June 9, 2022
